The question here is, how do you increase your average order value?

Every eCommerce business is faced with two major challenges: bringing down acquisition costs and increasing revenue per sale.

If you’re relying solely on acquiring new customers as a solution to these two problems, it’s not going to cut it.

Rather, focus on raising the buyer spend on each sale i.e. increase the AOV. 

And the best way to do it? Upselling.

Research says eCommerce businesses selling to an existing customer see 60-70% probable conversions whereas selling to a new customer sees only a 5-20% success. 

So let’s understand the What, Who, When, How, & Why of upselling and how you can use it to increase your AOV.

What is upselling?

In simplest terms, upselling is a sales technique wherein you offer your customers the chance to make purchase upgrades.

For eCommerce businesses, it means introducing or recommending the shopper a product that offers better features, better specifications, or more volume to them. This of course comes at a marginally higher cost. 

We all have come across upselling in some form or the other at some point in our lives.

Imagine ordering a cafe mocha at Starbucks and getting a recommendation to upgrade to a grande a just a little more cost — more chocolate, more coffee at just a minimal cost. Why not?

That’s how upselling works.

However, if Starbucks were too pushy about the upgrade, you would have declined the offer. This is where the upselling commandments come into play.

6 upselling commandments to keep in mind

1. Ditch the upselling blueprint and get to know your customers first 

All your customers are unique, and trying to fit them into the same box can be a grave mistake. What might seem lucrative for one might be a waste to another. 

For example, if you’re an antivirus software company selling a five devices plan, it’s not a right fit for a person who has only two devices to use. 

Understand what your customer needs. Take time to analyze their past purchases, their current needs, and how they fit into the upsell you’re offering.

2. Allow your customers to “experience” products first 

One of the key factors of a successful upsell is how good or valuable the customer thinks your products are, based on their previous purchase and shopping experience. The best way to do so is to ask them for feedback post-delivery.

Here’s an example:

Example of post-delivery feedback

Now if the customer shares positive feedback, you know they liked your product. You can then nudge them to purchase a subscription of the product or buy a bigger quantity of the same.

This is similar to how you wouldn’t buy a tall grande right away from Starbucks without knowing your favorite coffee blend or its strength. 

3. Highlight the value in your upsell offer clearly 

If Starbucks didn’t suggest you get a bigger cup of coffee instead, would you have yourself? Not really. 

This is because most often you choose to purchase something that you already want. Unless someone tells you that you could also have this along with that, you wouldn’t really go for it. 

Another factor is that you’d need a strong reason to spend your hard-earned money on something extra.  

Be it an increase in the quantity, a better feature, or simply the add-ons that come along with a particular product and/or service. 

For example, if a visitor is browsing through basic, single-tone t-shirts, show them a pack of 3 with a message “let us cover all your weekday lounge needs” and a discount to save on buying the 3 together — it’s a great way to nudge them to pay more than what they initially intended to. 

“Tell me how I win. If I win, you win”, said sales guru Jeffery Gitomer when someone asked him how they could upsell him a credit card. 

4. Be transparent about the pricing difference 

Irrespective of the brand or the value your upsell offer brings, most online shoppers have set a budget for their purchase. While they’d like to know about the options available to them, it’s also important for them to know how much of a difference they’d have to pay. 

When making an upsell offer, make sure you’re crystal clear about the pricing difference. 

Don’t be ambiguous. Tell them how much they’re saving on the purchase despite the upgrade. It makes your upsell offer more compelling. 

5. Segment your customers based on behavior for better personalization 

We’ve said it before. We’ll say it again. Every online shopper is different. 

But at the same time, some may display similar purchase behavior. Be it in terms of the products they like, the collections they’re interested in, what motivates them to make a purchase, and the upsell offers they tend to convert one. Use that data to categorize them into customer segments and detail them out like personas

This will help you create personalized upsell offers for each of the segments, that they are more likely to convert on. 36% of your customers actually expect this personalization. This is a great way to improve your AOV for each buyer. 

Want to know how top eCommerce brands use personalization to sell more? Read this.

6. Learn to accept a “no, thank you” 

Sometimes, even if it’s a rightly timed upsell or great value addition, the customer might not feel the need to upgrade. Be respectful of their choice and accept their decision. If you’re too pushy about the upgrade, you might just end up losing the customer. 

Now that you know the commandments of upselling, let’s get started with how to put this strategy to work. 

What should you be upselling? 

1. Most popular/ trending products

78% of consumers use the Internet to research and make sure they’re buying products of value. Buying a product/service has emotional factors connected to it. When people see that a product has been bought by many consumers, they feel more confident in buying it.

2. Behavior-based products

91% of consumers prefer to buy from brands that remember them. When you care to go through consumers’ past buying or product browsing behavior, you can provide relevant product options to them, which increases the likelihood of them buying it. 

Use a customer journey-based approach to gathering information about customers’ past purchase history. Then, make the upsell relevant to the past purchases of the customer. If a customer bought a mobile handset three years back from your eCommerce store, it’s most likely that they might need to change or upgrade or look for a new handset in the coming few months. 

3. Must-have/ need-based products 

Let’s say you’re buying a ring for yourself. But as you move towards checkout, you see an upsell offer that displays another ring with the message “what would you like for your better half?”. This may immediately consider you to make a purchase as the brand creates a ‘need’ for you to buy a ring for your partner as well. 

4. Upsell while making a cross-sell promotion 

To understand this, brands have to be clear about upsell and cross-sell. Here’s an example: when Apple persuades consumers to buy a better version of a phone, it’s upselling. And when Apple tries to sell complementing products with that phone, eg., earphones or a portable charger, it’s cross-selling. A combination of both can ensure higher sales, and in total, be a great upselling strategy. 

Make a list of products that go together really well or complement each other perfectly. Link one with the other to implement this strategy. Combining upsell and cross-sell promotions are a smart way to boost your AOV per buyer.

5. Product splinter or service slice 

Upselling means you need to introduce your shoppers to something better, but related to what they’re viewing or are interested in buying. But not every online store has as many products in the same collection or category, nor do they have the ability to create new products right away. 

This is where the product splinter strategy comes in. Here, you take a portion of your existing product and make its own new product. You can do the same with your services as well.

For example, you have an acne-reducing skincare product which is a mix of a mask and a hydrating lotion. You can actually invest in creating a mini-pack of your mask and lotion separately to let customers experience each before you introduce them to an all-in-one. 

But who should you be upselling to?

Who should you be upselling to? 

Upselling is not a strategy that you should restrict to only a set few customers. You can implement it for all the visitors to your store, no matter what stage of purchase journey they are at. 

But here are some customers that you should definitely consider upselling to: 

1. Your highest spenders 

Take a look at customers who have spent a lot on your store. Create a separate segment of these customers and study their sales history to identify their motivation behind investing in higher-value purchases. 

These are consumers that are willing to pay a premium to bag better products or avail of extra goodies. So make sure you’re offering them exactly that.

2. Your loyal customers 

Do you see a segment of shoppers that tend to make purchases from you time and again? These are consumers that trust your brand and are hence more likely to make a bigger commitment. 

Reach out to them with upsell offers that are similar to what they’ve purchased repeatedly. Make them feel valued by showing them you notice their preferences. 

3. Your first-time buyers 

First-time visitors to your store are more likely to leave without making a purchase. That makes upselling even more crucial to ensure they convert. Wondering how you can convince someone to make a higher-value purchase on their first visit? 

Use social proof to back it up and show them upsell offers that display top-rated featured or best-selling products that are similar to what they are exploring on the site.  

4. Your active browsers 

Window shopping is real even online. There will be many visitors who land at your store looking for one product but end up exploring other collections as well. Since they’re already willing to see what options are available to them, ensure you dynamically show relevant upsell offers as they move along the site. 

You never know what actually motivates them to make the purchase.

When should you be upselling? 

The answer to this varies based on the upsell strategy you intend to use. But a few golden rules to follow to know the right time to make an upsell offer are:

  • When you’ve given enough time to the visitor to find the product they’re looking for and understand the value it brings to them 
  • When you allow the customer to make a purchase to experience your products before making an upsell offer (eg. beauty and cosmetics) 
  • When you ensure your upsell offers are more intuitive than pushy and do not derail a visitor’s shopping journey 
  • When a trust moment occurs, i.e., a potential customer takes an action within your sales funnel that indicates their trust towards your brand is increasing

How should you be upselling? 

According to a study, upselling drives an average of over 4% of sales for an eCommerce business. In fact, it’s one of Amazon’s core strategies to increase their AOVs as well. 

But that happens when you upsell strategically in a way that the offers seem appealing to the online shoppers.

Graph of how upselling can increase eCommerce sales

1. Offer a side-by-side comparison of similar products  

One of the simplest ways to upsell is to offer a side-by-side comparison of similar products. It lets the shopper get a comprehensive view of the value they can get out of a product that might cost them a little more. 

The ease of comparison of value and pricing removes the need to move back and forth between product pages to consider upsell offers. This increases the chances of being able to visualize the higher value being presented to the shopper and eventually better conversions.

Product comparisons can help increase the AOV

2. Display the alternatives available on limited/ out of stock inventory 

There may be times when a product is out of stock or running on limited inventory. In this case, you can implement an upsell strategy that displays alternative products to the shopper. These alternatives could be higher priced than the product they were viewing, but need to remain contextual to their search. 

A simple “customers also viewed” section displaying these product recommendations can do the trick.

Suggesting alternatives is a great way to upsell

3. Give the shoppers an option to upgrade

The airline industry does this with finesse. First, it displays the actual price of flying to your destination. Once you decide the dates and proceed to checkout, it gives more options to choose food/seat upgrades with a price difference. If you’re a frequent flier, you’re bound to convert on them. 

Similarly, you can use this upsell strategy for your eCommerce business. As the shopper moves to checkout, display the available add-ons like gift wrapping, gift card, warranty, etc. 

But remember, here too, the upgrade you offer should add value to the purchase being made. 

4. Offer a minimum dollar threshold for free shipping 

Did you know that 9 out of 10 customers find free shipping as the greatest incentive for shopping online? Use this purchase behavior to upsell products on your store. 

Provide a minimum dollar threshold where you encourage customers to add more products to the cart to avail free shipping. This way you sell more as well as save on shipping costs by fulfilling orders of more products together.

Minimum dollar threshold can help increase the AOV

5. Show a discounted upsell after order completion on the thank you page 

A lot of brands apply an upselling strategy only when the customer is browsing through products. But you have an opportunity to upsell even when the customer has completed a purchase. 

You can do this by displaying upsell offers on your thank you page or nudging them to explore your discounts page for further upsell opportunities using an exit-intent popup. It’s like waiting for the customer to complete a purchase and then redirecting them back into the purchase journey. 

Example of discounted upsell

6. Subtly recommend similar products 

You step into a brick-and-mortar store to buy a t-shirt from their basic collection. But the salesperson talks you into checking out a similar t-shirt from their limited edition collection and immediately piques your interest. This is an upsell strategy that you can use in your store too. 

If you have a large inventory with similar products, showcase similar products on the product page. You can also recommend new collections relevant to the product search the shopper has made. 

Here’s how Net-a-Porter does it:

Example of product recommendation

7. Show alternatives with better product ratings

88% of consumers trust product reviews and ratings as much as personal recommendations. Now you can’t physically be around an online shopper to encourage them into checking out other similar products. But you can subtly push your upsell offers in front of them by displaying alternatives with better product ratings.  

This upsell strategy works because the higher ratings on an upsell let the shopper see how others like them find the product, and the value it has added to their lives. 

8. Display and highlight a popular choice 

Imagine walking into a store that displays three similar dresses in a row. But one of them has a label that says it has been picked as a must-have by a popular fashion magazine. You’re automatically swayed towards trying out this dress. 

Use the same psychology to make upsells on your online store. When you’re displaying similar products or upsell offers on the product page, cart page, the search results page, or even the exit-intent popup, highlight one which is popular with a sticker or a banner.

Example of adding trending or bestseller banners

9. Use popups for upselling 

Popups are an effective strategy to capture the visitor’s attention. Instead of only using them to promote your discounts and deals, use the space to make your upsell offers. You can implement different upsell campaigns on different pages for more effectiveness. 

For example, if a visitor is on the product page and is exiting the site, you can show an upsell offer, recommending a similar but better product at a 10% discount. 

Similarly, if the visitor is exiting from the thank you page, you can encourage them to make an upsell purchase by showing the offer on an exit-intent popup.

Upselling on popups is a great way to increase your AOV

10. Display upsell offers on your cart page 

Typically, online stores display the products added to the cart on their cart page, along with details on quantity, pricing, etc. But you can actually use this space to promote your upsell offers too. This is pretty much what Amazon does as well. 

When you add a product to your cart, it starts to display similar products that are ‘better’ than the one you picked right below it. This makes the shopper want to reconsider their purchase and buy a higher value product, especially if it’s accompanied by a better offer and ratings.

Example of upsell offers on the cart page

11. Implement quantity breaks or volume discounts 

BOGO discounts, buy one get one and similar deals are a big hit amongst both online and offline shoppers. This upsell strategy uses the simple rule of nudging the shopper to buy more of something to be able to avail of a discount. 

For some products, based on their nature, you can implement volume discounts or quantity breaks for smart upselling. 

Let’s say you’re selling a pair of socks for $10. You can create an upsell offer that nudges the shopper to get three pairs of socks at just $29. Considering how frequently we wear socks, the shopper is likely to convert on this deal. 

12. Provide high service tier trial products or mini quantities 

If you’ve recently launched a high-value product, consider offering either a trial product or a mini-packaging of the same. This lets the consumer experience the product, understand the value it brings to them, and makes them more receptive to converting when you upsell the actual product to them. 

Let’s take those perfume trials into account. The trial bottles let you experience what the perfume smells like before you actually have to buy it. 

13. Start upselling during checkout 

While it’s a good practice to keep your checkout as distraction-free as possible, running upsell campaigns there has proven to work effectively for many. 

Just as the visitor is moving towards completing the purchase, make them an offer that cannot be refused — free shipping, for instance. 

Let them know how far they are from availing free shipping and then display a few trending products in the same category below.

Example of upselling on the checkout page

14. Upsell via your communication channels 

Whether it’s email, web push, Facebook Messenger, or even SMS, use your common communication channels to upsell products. Don’t just restrict them to notify shoppers of the ongoing deals and discounts. 

For example, if a customer purchased a planner from you last month, use these channels to reach out to them and introduce your new range of weekly or monthly planners or productivity kits. 

Here’s an example of an email for upselling:

Email-based upselling

15. Set up retargeting and remarketing ads to promote upsell offers 

Another effective channel to upsell products to your customers is your retargeting and remarketing ads. Based on what a customer purchases or browses on your website, you can display product upsells through these channels to introduce them to something better, and more ‘value for money’.

Example of upselling on remarketing ads

And now that you know the different ways you can upsell to a customer, let’s tell you what you should be upselling. 

Like we said before, for an upsell campaign to work, your upsell offers need to be highly contextual and value-driven. 

Why is upselling important? 

The short answer is that a customer who is actively browsing through your products or has purchased from you before is more likely to buy a higher cart value product than a first-time visitor. It’s the easiest way to influence a consumer’s purchase decision in the most natural way possible. 

But we’ll give you a few more reasons: 

  1. Increases average order value 

When you upsell smartly, you can convince an online shopper to spend a ‘little’ more than what they initially had in mind. This helps you increase the average order value on your store easily. 

  1. Increases customer lifetime value and retention 

When you personalize your upsell offers to focus on adding more value to your customers, their experience with your brand improves. The better the experience, the longer they tend to stay with you as a customer, and the higher is the probability of them making more purchases. This increases both customer lifetime value and retention. 

  1. Improves customer experience 

Upselling essentially uses the theory of introducing shoppers to better products. This ensures that the online shopper makes a better purchase, one that is more likely to offer them a great post-purchase experience. 

While upselling has endless benefits to increase your overall sales and revenue, it’s not always the strategy to go for. Sometimes, you need to downsell as well to nudge a purchase. 

What is downselling? 

Downselling is another sales technique used by eCommerce businesses to ensure every visitor turns into a shopper by offering them an alternative that is more budget-friendly. Sometimes, it includes simply offering more convenient buying options to customers after they reject or decline an upsell offer you made. 

Is upselling for you? 

The short answer is, YES. 

Upselling is for everyone. If you’ve started to notice that your store visitors tend to buy a lower range of products when you have better ones to offer, set up an upsell campaign so that they can see the value in your higher-priced products as well. 

And as long as you’re adding value to the consumers, you’ll always succeed.

But as a parting note, remember that upselling isn’t a set and forget it strategy. Just like other marketing and sales campaigns, you need to continually monitor the response to your upsell offers and optimize them to suit your target audience better.

Comments to: Non-pushy ways to Upsell and Increase Average Order Value

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *